@EdenEyeI used to be super embarrassed too. The worst case scenario I can imagine is running into someone I know, but I'd probably play it tough like "Yeah I like these toys, so?!" (Well, actually I'm pretty timid ._..) The only other bad thing is being side-by-side with a 9-year-old girl and being as legitimately interested in the toys as she is. They notice it. o.o
But other than that no one else really seems to care thankfully! I really shouldn't be ashamed of it at all, though; and neither should you! Getting that feeling off your back is very liberating. Just remember: you'll probably never see those people again, nor will they remember you!!
I'd guess animal shelters don't bother with it because of the stuffing clean up. Or swallowing eyeballs or something dumb like that. But I completely see your point! Speaking of clueless workers, sometimes my thrift stores get a little self-righteous and overcharge stupid things like crazy! Like $8 - $14 for a vintage Garfield plush.. hello?? No thank you.
I don't have any friends around here that I can relate to with toys either. I think we're in a pretty small niche. XD A happy one though!! Okay, I win the long-winded award.
@EricaVeeYeah, that's always a great alibi.

"Oh this? I have this niece who... " xDD.
-Em